CBS Anchor Scott Pelley says Journalism's House Is On Fire

"If you're first, no one will ever remember. If you're wrong, no one will ever forget."

CBS Evening News Anchor Scott Pelley called on journalists to worry less about the "vanity"of being first on a breaking news story and to worry more about being right. He made the criticism while accepting a journalism award May 10, 2013 from Quinnipiac University. Pelley says mistakes are being made because reporters often use information from uncorroborated pages of social media. He rallied against "vanity" and "self-conceit," as the drivers of a real-time scramble to be first with any new crumb of information posted on Twitter, Facebook and Reddit.

"This is not journalism. That's gossip. Journalism was invented as an antidote to gossip," said Pelley. "It's a world where everybody is a publisher and no one is an editor. We're getting the big stories wrong over and over again." Pelley added up the mountain of mistakes -  from the Newtown school massacre, the Boston Marathon Bombings to the escape of three women held hostage in a Cleveland house for 10 years -  as evidence that journalism's house in on fire.

Video of the awards ceremony at Quinnipiac University

Scott Pelley's speech starts at the 10:30 mark.


Check out exclusive kowchmedia tips on breaking news coverage further down on this page.

Check out the On The Kowch Blog for a Canadian perspective about what is happening in media.

Five things to do during breaking news coverage

  1. Provide listeners with a reason to listen to your radio station or watch your television station. What is the benefit of coming to you vs your competition. In times of disaster it is more than just telling people what happened. You create a benefit for coming to your media outlet by giving them information they can use to stay out of harm's way or to help themselves. Figure out what you or your family would need to know if something like this happened in your listening or viewing area. Ask staff what kind of information they would need to get them through a hurricane, tornado, earthquake or major snowstorm. Then build that into your coverage plans.

  2. Fine tune your social media strategies to connect with as many users as possible with critical information. TV stations can post anchored updates on YouTube.  Battery powered laptops, smartphones and WIFI make it possible to go online to watch the videos. Extreme news events are typically good for 10% spikes in Facebook, Twitter and Skype and YouTube memberships. Promote your social media connections and encourage listeners/viewers to use the social media to update you on what is happening in their neighbourhoods.

  3. In times of extreme emergencies the cellular phone networks crash under the crush of everyone calling family and friends to see if they are OK. This will create a major headache to have listeners or reporters all in with live updates. That is when you need to use modern technology like Skype. Reporters can use a Smartphone to dial your Skype line to get on air and even show video on TV. (Battery powered laptops with access to WIFI can also log on to Skype). The public can call the radio station or TV station to go on air to report what they see via Skype. If your station doesn't use Skype now, get your engineering department to hook you up. More importantly, have the engineers hook Skype up in master control so you can put people using Skype on the air. Don't wait until something happens. Do it now while it's still fresh in your mind.

  4. Cellular phones may crash but texting will still work. It is a different server on the network. Make sure your station has a texting account to receive crucial updates from citizen journalists. Do it now. It takes time to set this up. You can't do it at the last minute or during a natural disaster. Remember, if you have a texting network it works both ways. You can send your listeners/viewers text message updates including promoting upcoming coverage like a live press conference.

  5. Create a "Go-Team" plan where you share human resources with sister stations in your company. This was a major initiative by US stations during Hurricane Irene to roll in reinforcements to load up personnel in major-news areas depending on the need. Sort of a mutual aid system like fire departments have with neighbouring communities. If your company has stations across the province start figuring out your mutual aid system now.

  • More exclusive kowchmedia breaking news coverage tips below.

Breaking News Coverage Tips

It's a person. A doctor pronounces her dead. Not the news.

Make this headline your computer screen saver.

Blow it up and post it in the newsroom, master control, the main studio and in the news booth.

It's a great quote from the fourth episode of HBO'sThe Newsroom .  It should be the rule when media is dealing with breaking news and has to decide whether or not to report that someone has died.

It's a person. A doctor pronounces her dead. Not the news.

The quote comes from a senior producer who rejects demands by the president of ACN Network to order anchor Will McAvoy to report that Congresswoman Gabby Giffords is dead because all the other TV networks were reporting she died after being shot in the head during a political rally.

News Night anchor McAvoy listens to the producer and ignores his boss. The message that it's a person and only a doctor can pronounce someone dead, not a news network is something to live by in a breaking news situation when other news outlets are reporting the unconfirmed death of someone.

While the show is fiction, the story line is true. The congresswoman was declared dead by one news outlet and everyone else jumped on the bandwagon to report she had died from the gun shot to the head. Turns out, she wasn't dead and today she is making an incredible recovery.

If you're not in media, you can't appreciate the pressure that exists during breaking news stories involving famous people when they're injured in an accident, victims of foul play, illness or just old age. One news outlet reports the person is dead and bosses are shouting why don't we have the story.

The bigger the name, the more pressure to follow the crowd and declare them dead. Funny how there is never a rush in media to kill off someone who isn't famous.

Here's another quote worth plastering the radio station with:

Better to be last and right than first and wrong when reporting someone has died

You can quote me on this one.

The need to be first does not outweigh the need to be right.

Especially when dealing with important breaking news stories and high profile individuals.

Just because it's on the internet doesn't mean it's true.

Just because the competition is saying it doesn't make it true.

Confirm! Confirm! Confirm!

Call the person. Call their family. Call their place of employment.

Believe me, it's better to call for confirmation than have to call to apologize later for saying that person was dead when they weren't.


When news breaks you need to let everyone not listening to your radio station at the time know what is happening. Twitter the news with a link to your station website coverage. If you're doing it right the user name of your Twitter account should be the radio station or name of your show.

Social media should not be an afterthought anymore. It is needs to be part of your plan to bring people to your station in time of breaking news coverage.


Update Twitter constantly with NEW information. Tweet followers what is coming up in your breaking news coverage. For example promote on Twitter time of press conference being carried live. Tweet reporter about to go live from the scene. Tweet latest info from the scene or quote an eye witness.

You need to spread the word to get people to tune in to hear what you're doing live right now.

If you don't let the world know about your live breaking news coverage, you'll only be taking to those who are tuned in at the time. Tell the world and invite them to listen online or to your radio station. Tell them and they will come to your station. Don't and they'll go to the other station doing a better job of promoting their breaking news coverage on social media.


There is no bigger breaking news story than on election night.

To provide the results it has to be all hands on deck.

Reporters and any other on air people should be at key riding headquarters in your market. Make sure you go to them often on the air. Make sure they get you the winning and losing candidates on air to be interviewed by your broadcast team in master control.

You will need two anchors on election night to do updates every 15 minutes.

Top and bottom of the hour use one anchor for overall results. Assign a producer to help them line up the reporters or interviews. At :15 and :45 use a second anchor who also has a producer working with them. This means each anchor is on the air only once a half hour.

It is a busy but manageable pace for the anchors. But they must have a producer to assist them in coordinating the contributors for their updates.


The number one mistake newsrooms make when breaking news happens is sending EVERYONE to the scene. Yes, you want to send as many people as possible to where the news event is happening. But you need to also keep some people available to go to the hospital.

Chances are by the time your news teams arrive on the scene, the injured have been transported to hospital for treatment of their injuries. You need someone to be at the hospital because this is where the victims can tell you their stories.

The key word here is: victims. They are an important part of the story.

You get eye witnesses at the scene. But you can usually only get victims at the hospital.

Now you're probably asking, how can I interview the victims if they are being treated. Well, those with minor injuries will be released and available to talk. But what most news people don't understand is that a lot of times people who were on the scene with the victims go to the hospital to be with them.

It stands to reason. If you're with someone injured in a crash, an explosion or whatever. You want to be with them at the hospital.

The hospital is also where families of the victims go.

It is also where you will get accurate information about the number of injuries and fatalities from hospital officials. An important part of the story. You also have access to police, EMS and firemen who were at the scene.

By splitting up your teams and sending them to different locations you will provide a more comprehensive sounding coverage to your listeners. This is what will set you apart from your competition. It will give you an edge on breaking news coverage.


The best way to beat the competition during breaking news is not wait for confirmation from authorities to send a reporter.

We're not suggesting you go on air with unconfirmed information. We're suggesting don't wait for confirmation to mobilize the troops to get to the scene of the event.

That is the job of the reporter. To go and find out what is happening. But too many newsrooms wait for authorities to get back to them with details before a decision is made to go to the scene. Usually it's because of lazy reporters who don't want to leave the comfort of their newsroom to chase what they think might be a false alarm. Or someone is afraid to make the call for fear it is a false alarm and the reporter gets upset with them

I've chased more than my share of false alarms when I was a street reporter. No big deal. It's the nature of the job.

But I also beat the competition a lot of times because I sprung into action as soon as I heard the call over the police radio. Arriving with the cops minutes after a bank robber blew himself up or with firemen as people jumped from a burning nightclub.

The further away the event is unfolding, the faster you have to make a decision to go and check it out. The newsroom can always call you off the chase if they find out it's not as bad as first feared.

In radio and television you build your reputation and that of the newsroom on how quick you react to a situation to get to the scene before the competition.

Again, just to be clear. I'm advocating don't wait for confirmation from authorities about what sounds like a major breaking news story to head to the scene. I'm NOT saying go to air with unconfirmed information. And I definitely don't think a reporter should be tweeting information about unconfirmed reports until they know it's true. Then they can tweet they're on the way to the event or once they arrive.


The best way to beat the competition during breaking news is to ask listeners to call in and describe on air what they see happening at the scene.

When Air France Flight 358 crashed at Toronto's Pearson Airport in August of 2005 most radio stations waited for their reporters to get to the scene or to rely on authorities to provide them updates.

But traffic chaos around the airport delayed the arrival of reporters and authorities were slow in releasing information.

The radio stations who encouraged listeners near the scene or driving along the 401 by the airport to call in and describe what they were seeing provided the best news coverage of the event. 680News won an award on the strength of a caller who happened to be driving by when the plane skidded off the runway and burst into flames.

A few years later when forest fires threatened Kelowna, BC an FM music station turned to citizen journalism to provide listeners with the latest information. Along the way that station won a Canadian Association of Broadcasters Gold Ribbon Award for its coverage.

For info or a quote on kowchmedia services

  • airchecks
  • radio demo tapes
  • station monitors
  • writing web content
  • social media postings
  • brochure writing
  • corporate videos
  • video testimonials
  • webinars
  • on air coaching
  • News room coaching
  • Program Director coaching
  • management consulting
  • social media content
  • CBSC complaints
  • CRTC radio station applications

Contact Us Page

Steve Kowch | Phone

647 521-6397

Send monitors and aircheck audio files to

steve@kowchmedia.com

must read for people in media

Astral releases PPM study of ratings during Federal Election

Expect Ontario stations not to spend a lot of money covering Fall election

The Spring 2011 PPM video analysis from Astral Media is not good news for Ontario news directors who want to send a reporter on the campaign bus in the Fall.

Astral looked at newstalk radio station ratings across Canada during the federal election campaign. What they found was a drop in ratings during the actual campaign and bump in ratings on election night.

Edmonton and Anglo Montrealers were the least interested in radio election results.

Edmonton newstalk stations had the lowest ratings of all five markets during the election campaign dropping 13%. Vancouver newstalk stations dropped nine per cent and Toronto ratings fell by eight per cent.

Astral's PPM election analysis leaves no doubt that it's just not worth it for radio to spend a lot of money on election campaign coverage.

It's NOT What You Talk About ... It's HOW You Talk About It!

kowchmedia provides you the Canadian perspective on the newstalk radio format.

No one knows newstalk radio in Canada like Steve Kowch. He has 14 years experience running two of Canada's largest newstalk radio stations. As the national director of the talk format for the largest radio chain in Canada, he mentored hosts, program directors and news directors at six stations.

Steve can help take your announcing, reporting or anchoring career to the next level in radio with personalized affordable airchecks.

Let kowchmedia make a difference at YOUR radio station. Book your station monitor today. Steve hears what you don't hear on your radio station.

Email or call Steve at 647 521-6397 today for more information about personalized airchecks, station monitors or coaching on air news and talk talent.

Steve helps future broadcasters and broadcast journalists chase their dream for a successful career in media. He taught at two Toronto area colleges. Among the courses he taught are intro to radio, intro to radio news, radio features and talk radio. He is the author of 99 Things You Wish You Knew Before Making It BIG In Media.

Read Steve's weekly blog: On The Kowch

Follow Steve on Twitter and Facebook

News Testimonial

Under his leadership, Steve turned Standard Broadcast News from a virtually unknown Canadian news wire service and national news network into a highly competitive team of journalists whose daily reports earned the industry's respect.

-Malcolm Bernard, owner Interplay Creative Media in Ottawa and former Parliament Hill Bureau Chief at Standard Broadcast News in Ottawa

Walter Sabo Testimonial

Structure, discipline, and a scientific understanding of how media works is rare and valuable. For 10 years I worked with the successful Steve Kowch and can confidently say he is the best News media executive in North American radio. There are good “news” managers and good “talk show” producers, Kowch excels at both.

- Walter Sabo, Chairman, Sabo Media and Hitviews.com, New York

Radio Management Consulting

  • Experience in developing talent on air and behind the scenes to work as a team to create great radio

  • Unique way of conducting monitors to help make it easier to solve on air problems

  • Coach music PDs on the best way to mentor opinionated talk show hosts on the air

On Air Host & Talent Airchecks

  • For talk show hosts: It’s not what you talk about! It’s how you talk about it.

  • For music DJs: It’s not how long you have to talk. It’s how you fill time before the music starts.

  • Unique way of conducting show monitors makes it easier for talent to fix their on air problems

Broadcast Student Resources

  • We’re here to help students ace their radio assignments with our constructive feedback

  • We provide student broadcasters airchecks of their campus radio shows or newscasts

  • We help students chase their dream for a career in radio either on air or behind the scenes